Skip to content

Board Dysfunction: Who is Ultimately Responsible?

Board Dysfunction Who is Ultimately Responsible

We have all seen the data and research on how board diversity improves the bottom line.  The message is clear, take diversity seriously, make the necessary changes, and your company will thrive. Additionally, the PWC 2020 Corporate Governance Survey showed that 49% of directors believe that at least one director on their board needs to step down, and 21% say that two directors need to go. 

One would think that if board diversity is a proven way to increase profitability in one’s company, and many boards have at least one dud-director, why aren’t we making more progress? All of the data seems to point to complacency. I’ve been struggling to understand this lack of motivation to address the shortfalls in the board room. In the same PWC study, only 12% of boards chose not to renominate a director, and only 14% was a director asked to retire from the board. Why are Chairmen and Nominating Committees willing to wait out low performers? Why are they willing to forego a high-performing, results-driven board? 

One of the most compelling findings I uncovered as I struggled with this question is that there are thousands of articles on term limits and age limits, but few on how to ask a director to resign. I recently spoke with the private company Chairman of a diversified portfolio of businesses. In our discussion, she mentioned that this unwillingness to have a difficult conversation or make a difficult decision is what is keeping boards from taking that first step towards a high-functioning diverse board.

Waiting for a director to age out or term out is the recipe for a low-functioning board that won’t bring strategic value to the business. Avoidance of these challenging conversations prevents all of the positive things that come with change. Bringing on new, diverse directors will energize your board. You will be challenged in your common precepts; you will find yourself having a more robust dialog about the company’s issues and challenges. Your board will deliver greater value to the company. Given the cost of time and money to have a board, it is the Chairman’s responsibility to get the most out of its directors by being willing to do the most formidable job, have the difficult conversation.



Share This Post

Connect with Meghan

Meghan Juday Advisory – Learn more about her work helping families establish or refine family or corporate governance

Speaking – Discuss upcoming speaking opportunities, whether at a conference, podcast, or interview.

Advocacy – Learn more about Meghan’s work with women in family business leadership, including her work with The Lodis Forum